Bakeshop

Your local bakers

  • Add Your Bakery
  • Log In
  • 0 Unread Messages
  • FAQs
  • About
Menu
  • Add Your Bakery
  • Log In
  • 0 Unread Messages
  • FAQs
  • About

Custom Sugar Cookies

New York, NY
Cookies
4 Reviews
1 Favorite
Add Photos
Write a Review

Creating customized sugar cookies perfect for any occasion! Great for party favors, dessert table decoration, or even as a unique and personalized gift! Email below for design ideas and pricing, or check out @notyourgrannyscookies on Instagram for more creations!

Photo Gallery

Delivery Options

Pick up from baker
Custom Sugar Cookies

Not Your Grannys Cookies

Member since June 2020
Send Message

Only registered users can send messages. Please log in to continue.

Seller Profile
New York, NY
notyourgrannyscookies@gmail.com
Get Directions

Write a Review

Sort By

  1. Avatar
    Sydney

    Cutest cookies I’ve ever bitten into. 10/10 would recommend.

    5 years ago
  2. Avatar
    Marisa M

    Not Your Granny’s Cookies made “FRIENDS” themed cookies for my Friendsgiving gathering, and they were a hit! Such beautiful and creative cookies that looked too good to eat. Normally I don’t love the flavor of this style of cookie, but these looked AND tasted amazing. I will definitely order from here again and again!

    5 years ago
  3. Avatar
    Carlye Richter

    I ordered Not Your Granny’s Cookies for my sister’s engagement party and everyone kept asking me where I got them from! They were beautifully customized for my sister and her fiancé and tasted delicious! I will certainly be ordering Not Your Granny’s Cookies for every special occasion!

    5 years ago
  4. Avatar
    Brittany Urkiel

    NYGC made custom cookies for my husband’s 30th birthday and they were so perfect. I gave a few rough design requests and the cookies were more than I could have imagined. They looked absolutely incredible and tasted even better. Highly, highly recommend!!

    5 years ago
  5. Avatar
    Alexandra Hoover

    Not Your Granny’s Cookies is so awesome! I had cookies made for my going away party before I moved to California, and they were a hit. Personalized, beautiful, and delicious too!! Can’t wait to order more!

    5 years ago

Cancel reply

Your Rating Oops! you forgot to give a rating.

Copyright Bakeshop © 2025. All Rights Reserved
  • Instagram
  • FAQs

Login

Use a social account for faster login or easy registration.

Log in with Facebook Log in with Google

or

Lost your password?

Sign up for Bakeshop

A password will be sent to your email address.

Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.

Insert/edit link

Enter the destination URL

Or link to existing content

    No search term specified. Showing recent items. Search or use up and down arrow keys to select an item.